| Unlockable: | How to Unlock: |
| A-Train (Bronze) | Manually break 3 tackles during a Campaign Mode game. |
| Alpha Dog (Silver) | Train Franchise up to an A+ rating during Campaign Mode. |
| Anger Management (Bronze) | Accumulate 5 late hit icons in a single Campaign Mode game. |
| Big Spender (Silver) | Spend over a million dollars in Campaign mode. |
| Bulldozer (Bronze) | Get 10 sacks with Franchise in one Campaign Mode game. |
| Contender (Bronze) | Win a game online. |
| Dr. Feelgood (Bronze) | Successfully perform 10 Great Triages (over 90%) in Campaign Mode. |
| Early Release (Bronze) | Beat Prison Ball in Campaign Mode. |
| Face of the League (Gold) | Finish Campaign Mode. |
| Faithful (Bronze) | Be faithful to 1 girl throughout Campaign Mode. |
| Floater (Bronze) | Intercept three passes in a game. |
| Full Deck (Silver) | Win an Online game with every team. |
| Go Long! (Bronze) | Gain 450 passing yards in any Campaign Mode game. |
| Group Hug (Bronze) | Land 3 three man tackles in any Campaign Mode, Quick Play or Bonus Mode game. |
| Hall of Fame (Gold) | Franchise declared the MVP in all three division seasons. |
| He's Ready (Bronze) | Complete Training Mode. |
| Hollywood (Bronze) | Perform 5 different touchdown celebrations in a single game. |
| Hot Streak (Silver) | Win 5 games in a row online with any teams. |
| House Rules (Silver) | Win a game against the computer in every Bonus Mode. |
| Ironman (Bronze) | Score 5 TD's and get 5 sacks with Franchise in a single Campaign Mode game. |
| Jackpot (Bronze) | Earn $400,000 in one campaign mode game. |
| King of the Yard (Bronze) | Shut out the computer in a Bonus Mode game of Prison Ball. |
| Legendary Rookie (Silver) | Beat Division 3 in Campaign Mode. |
| Legendary Sophomore (Silver) | Beat Division 2 in Campaign Mode. |
| Lockdown (Bronze) | Shut out an opponent in an online game. |
| Lucky 7's (Bronze) | Throw at least 7 TD passes in a single game in Campaign Mode. |
| Magic Hands (Bronze) | Catch every pass thrown by your QB in any Campaign Mode game. |
| Main Man (Silver) | Get Franchise's Reputation to 25 level or higher in Campaign Mode. |
| Man Blanket (Bronze) | Force 3 turnovers with Franchise during a Division Season in Campaign Mode. |
| MVP (Silver) | Franchise declared the MVP in any division season. |
| Parole Violation (Bronze) | Injure an opponent with Karl Tirpitz in Campaign Mode. |
| Platinum Trophy (Platinum) | Unlock all trophies. |
| Playah (Bronze) | Hook up with 3 different girls in Campaign Mode. |
| Power Surge (Bronze) | Score three TD's in a single quarter in Campaign Mode. |
| Real Deal (Bronze) | Win three games in a row online with your Campaign Mode custom team. |
| Return to Sender (Bronze) | Return two kickoff or punt returns for TD's in any game. |
| Rushing Attack (Bronze) | Score 5 rushing TD's in any Campaign Mode game. |
| Safety Dance (Bronze) | Force a safety in a single Campaign Mode, Quick Play or Bonus Mode game. |
| Sandman (Bronze) | Complete 3+ sacks with Quentin Sands in a single Campaign Mode game. |
| Showoff (Bronze) | Perform 10 different TD celebrations with Franchise in Campaign Mode. |
| Skidmark (Bronze) | Cause 3 weather slips to your opponent in a Campaign Mode game. |
| Stiffarmed (Bronze) | Injure 2 defenders in a single game in Campaign Mode. |
| The Clap (Bronze) | Play someone with the Clap in online play and you get the Clap. |
| Welcome Rookie (Bronze) | Win first game of Campaign Mode. |